Beyond The Obvious: A Journey Into Black-Box Penetration Testing

QA Automation Company

Did you know that almost three lac phishing incidents were reported in 2023, resulting in a loss of 10.3 billion USD? It underscores the importance of cyber security for any business. However, cyber threats are more complicated and are not always measured in the financial losses. Data privacy is also a major concern related to cyber security.  

Data breaches risk consumer information and threaten the company’s reliability. As a result, organizations try to figure out a robust solution. Black box testing can be an optimum solution. It not only safeguards the application from cyber threats. But it also ensures data integrity and provides expected system behavior. Organizations can also simulate various real-world cyber attacks with the help of ethical hacking. It helps them in finding system flaws and vulnerabilities.  

Let’s learn more about blind box testing to witness how it can safeguard your crucial data. 

Black Box Penetration Test

Often known as behavioral or functional testing, it is a software testing method without prior knowledge of the internal workings. During the test, a tester provides an input and notes down the output generated by the system. He then compares the generated output with the desired result regarding reliability and response time. This way, he identifies the flaws or the bugs within the system.  

This testing offers an end-to-end testing mechanism, making it a robust testing solution for modern-day applications. Testers can simulate original cyber-attacks to determine the application’s behavior. It helps them to identify actual security threats to determine the vulnerability and weakness within the application.   

Advantages VS Disadvantages Of A Black Box Pen Test Approach 

Black Box Penetration Testing Benefits 

Real-World Attacks Stimulation 

A black-box test replicates real-world attack scenarios, unveiling unexpected outcomes. 

Limited Source Code Insight 

Black-box testing only provides a limited understanding of your source code and internal processes. 

Low Budget 

Companies don’t require highly skilled testers to perform penetration testing. It significantly reduces the cost of the testing process. Additionally,  creating test cases is also simple, which further reduces the effort and time.   

Reveals Runtime Issues 

Assessing the application during runtime pinpoints implementation and configuration problems. 

Unbiased Testing 

During testing, a tester needs more information about the internal codes of the applications. As a result, the developer does not influence the testing process, making it a more reliable and accurate methodology.   

Disadvantages Of Black-Box Penetration Testing 

Incompletion of  Security Assurance 

Discovering issues in a black-box pentest indicates weak security but doesn’t guarantee overall security. Internal issues may remain concealed. 

Relies on External Guesswork 

This testing depends on the external party’s guesswork and trial-and-error methods, leading to varying testing durations. Depending on the pentester’s expertise and other factors, it might range from quick identification of vulnerabilities to months of surveys. 

Stages In A Black Box Penetration Test 


It is the first Step in the black box testing often known as the surveillance phase. During this, a tester collects all the information available in the public domain about the network topology and operating system. The main objective of this Step is to develop an effective strategy.     

Scanning & Enumeration 

The next step is the scanning process,, where a tester identifies open ports with the help of various tools. This step is essential as it helps locate various entry points from where an attacker can penetrate the application.   

Vulnerability Discovery 

Using the data gathered during the survey as a foundation, the penetration tester now looks for publicly known vulnerabilities and potential access points to the target system. This procedure includes locating known Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVEs), vulnerable software iterations, and probable flaws in third-party programs utilized by the target. 


As the name suggests, during this phase of black box testing, a tester carefully examines the application from the outside. The main objective of performing the exploration phase is experimenting with the application. This phase helps in discovering any unexpected behavior or problem. The tester provides various commands or even simulates user actions in the applications. 

Privilege Escalation 

Once the tester successfully penetrates the application, he enters the privilege phase. During this phase, a tester tries to elevate their role to a higher position in the application. This way,, the tester identifies security flaws in the application. The privilege escalation phase is crucial in strengthening the software defense against unauthorized access. 

5 Common Black-Box Techniques 

Equivalence Partitioning 

A tester bifurcates the inputs and outputs into various classes in this technique. The elements belonging to a group have the same characteristics. With the help of this technique, automation testing companies can test a range of values in a short period. That increases their efficiency and also improves testing accuracy. Generally, companies divide inputs into valid and invalid partitions where a valid partition contains values accepted by the app under testing.  

On the other hand, the invalid portion contains invalid values. The app does not accept these values. Depending upon the application’s needs, a tester can further subdivide the partition. To produce accurate results, testers must test invalid portions individually.      

Decision Table Testing 

This technique is used in penetration testing when several input combinations produce variable outputs. Thus, this analysis ensures a tester that all possible combinations are considered. It’s like ensuring the vending machine dispenses the correct item for a particular variety. Before performing decision table analysis, a tester must list all the conditions affecting the system’s behavior.  

Next, he must determine the possible inputs and corresponding outputs. One of the significant advantages of performing decision table testing is that it helps identify issues related to a particular combination. Further decision table testing allows a systematic approach which saves time and effort.     

Boundary Value Analysis 

This technique determines the limit values for a valid input for an application. It is crucial as it helps a QA Automation Company identify the applications’ breaking point. A tester checks the application with a value before and after these boundaries during this analysis. For example, if a field in the application accepts values between 1-100. Then, the tester may input minimum and maximum values within this limit to determine the applications’ nature and behavior.   

BVA helps determine potential errors that might go unnoticed during normal testing. It also saves time and resources without affecting the quality of testing. It helps a tester to ensure that the application performance is as expected, even at the boundaries. It is crucial for the stability and robustness of the application.  

State Transition Testing 

This testing technique examines the application behavior concerning the same input. To perform this testing, a tester must have a clear picture of the several transition stages of the application. It must know the conditions or inputs causing the transition of the applications. Then, only he can create scenarios for testing the applications. Performing this test is crucial for ensuring the correct transition between the applications’ different stages.  

It also ensures a smooth transition for unmatched customer experience. Through this STT, a tester can determine the loopholes as it undergoes various changes. It also helps create an effective testing strategy for applications with complex behavior.     

Black Box Penetration Testing Checklist 

This checklist can help a tester ensure comprehensive application testing: 

  • Understanding the requirements of the software is crucial.  
  • Next, Identify equivalence classes for input data. 
  • Now, determine the boundary value and test inputs at the boundary. 
  • Then, create a decision table and identify different states of transition. 
  • Design the test case and validate the application behavior. 
  • Validate the GUI elements to ensure that the app appearance is correct. 
  • Perform the functional testing to verify the response time and stability of the applications. 
  • Next, do the security testing to identify the vulnerabilities within the application. 

Wrap Up 

A company or a tester must have access to their resources before conducting black box testing. Apart from this, creating a reasonable budget is also crucial. Highlighting the areas for improvement can further improve the test results. Hiring experts to implement these tests is always preferable as they have the necessary expertise in the field. They not only assist you in detecting vulnerabilities but can also provide essential remedies. 

The following two tabs change content below.


Co-Founder & Director, Business Management
AutomationQA is a leading automation research company. We believe in sharing knowledge and increasing awareness, and to contribute to this cause, we try to include all the latest changes, news, and fresh content from the automation world into our blogs.